This morning, because it’s accomplished for the previous a number of years, the California Division of Motor autos launched a batch of reviews from the businesses piloting self-driving autos within the state. By legislation, all corporations actively testing autonomous vehicles on public roads in California are required to reveal the variety of miles pushed and the way typically human drivers have been compelled to take management of their autos, in any other case referred to as a “disengagement.”

Formally, the DMV defines disengagements as “deactivation of the autonomous mode when a failure of the autonomous know-how is detected or when the protected operation of the car requires that the autonomous car check driver disengage the autonomous mode and take fast handbook management of the car.” Critics say it leaves wiggle room for corporations to withhold details about sure failures, just like the operating of purple lights with a view to keep away from crosswalks. However whereas there’s credence to this, in lieu of federal guidelines, the reviews are one of many few metrics by which the progress of the trade’s pack leaders may be in contrast.

In accordance with the DMV, AV allow holders — of which there are 60 — traveled roughly 2.88 million miles in autonomous mode on California’s public roads through the reporting interval — a rise of greater than 800,000 miles from the earlier reporting cycle. Presently, 64 corporations have legitimate permits to check autonomous autos with a security driver on California public roadways.


Waymo drove 1.45 million miles in California in 2019, eclipsing the corporate’s 1.2 million miles in 2018, 352,000 miles in 2017, and 635,868 miles in 2016. Certainly, it was a yr of mileage milestones for the Alphabet subsidiary, which handed 1,500 month-to-month lively riders in Phoenix, Arizona — the one state of the 9 wherein Waymo has pushed the place its business taxi service, Waymo One, is out there. Waymo introduced earlier this yr that its autonomous Chrysler Pacificas and Jaguar I-Tempo electrical SUVs have pushed tens of billions of miles via laptop simulations and 20 million miles on public roads in 25 cities (up from 10 million a yr in the past).

The corporate’s disengagement charges, however, dropped from zero.09 per 1,000 self-driven miles (or one per 11,017 miles) to zero.076 per 1,000 self-driven miles (one per 13,219 miles). That’s in contrast with 2017, when Waymo reported 63 engagements for your entire yr.

The enhancements are maybe partly attributable to Waymo’s AI data-mining strategies impressed by Google Photographs and Google Search, in addition to the corporate’s ongoing collaboration with Alphabet’s DeepMind on AI strategies impressed by evolutionary biology. DeepMind’s PBT (Inhabitants Based mostly Coaching), which begins with a number of machine studying fashions and replaces underperforming members with “offspring,” managed to cut back false positives by 24% in pedestrian, bicyclist, and motorcyclist recognition duties whereas slicing coaching time and computational assets in half.

Individually, Waymo says it’s at the moment creating its fifth-generation Waymo Driver in Silicon Valley, San Francisco, and Los Angeles, and it says it runs disengagements via its simulation program. Later this yr, it plans to share extra on the protection framework it’s creating.

Waymo hasn’t shared the variety of prospects who’ve ridden in its fleet of over 600 autos thus far, but it surely stated final December that over 1,500 persons are utilizing its ride-hailing service month-to-month and that it’s tripled the variety of weekly rides since January 2019. Moreover, it revealed that it’s served over 100,000 complete rides since launching its rider applications in 2017, and it reiterated that, shortly after saying a partnership with Lyft to deploy 10 vehicles on the ride-hailing platform in Phoenix, a portion of its self-driving taxis not have a security driver behind the wheel. Utterly driverless rides stay accessible solely to a “few hundred” riders in Waymo’s Early Rider program, the corporate says.

In a transfer that laid naked Waymo’s ambitions for the profitable freight transportation trade, the corporate not too long ago introduced it’s going to start testing Peterbilt vans retrofitted with its tech stack on “promising” business routes in Texas, New Mexico, San Francisco Bay Space, Michigan, Arizona, Georgia, and on Metro Phoenix freeways (in addition to on the I-10 between Phoenix and Tucson). This got here after Waymo started mapping the streets of Los Angeles to review congestion and expanded testing to highways in Florida between Orlando, Tampa, Fort Myers, and Miami.

GM Cruise

Cruise Automation, the GM subsidiary that’s estimated to be value over $14.6 billion, reported a major uptick in miles pushed. Its retrofitted Chevy Bolts racked up 831,zero40 miles in 2019, up from 447,621 miles in 2018, 131,676 miles in 2017, and 9,776 miles in 2016.

Cruise recorded disengagements for the primary half of 2019 separate from these recorded within the second half of 2019, reflecting what it says was a mixture of upgrades and revamped testing procedures that drastically minimize down on disengagements per mile. Within the first half of 2019, Cruise reported 43 disengagements (or 7,635 miles per disengagement) in 328,285 complete miles pushed, in contrast within the second half of 2019 with 25 disengagements (or 20,110 miles per disengagement) in 502,755 miles. That works out to 68 complete disengagements in 2019, versus 86 disengagement in 2018 (as soon as each 5,205 miles) and 105 disengagements in 2017.

For a body of reference, that’s throughout the roughly 180 self-driving autos Cruise was working in California as of early 2019, up from 130 in June 2017.

Dan Ammann, Cruise’s CEO, not too long ago gave a glimpse on the progress it’s made towards a completely self-driving car fleet. Throughout GM’s investor day convention in New York, he revealed that Cruise has decreased the period of time between software program updates whereas slicing the time it takes to coach its AI fashions by 80%. Main new firmware rolls out up 45 occasions extra incessantly than earlier than, and as typically as twice weekly.

Cruise runs numerous simulations throughout its suite of inside instruments — about 200,000 hours of compute jobs every day in Google Cloud Platform as of April 2019 — considered one of which is an end-to-end, three-dimensional Unreal Engine setting that Cruise workers name The Matrix. Over 30,000 cases spin up each day throughout 300,000 processor cores and 5,000 graphics playing cards, every of which loops via a single drive’s value of eventualities and generates 300 terabytes of outcomes.

Cruise operates an employees-only ride-hailing program in San Francisco referred to as Cruise Anyplace that permits those that make it past the waitlist to make use of an app to get round mapped areas. Individually, constructing on the progress it’s made up to now, Cruise has a partnership with DoorDash to pilot meals and grocery supply within the Bay Space for choose prospects. The corporate additionally continues to make progress towards its Origin car idea, which options computerized doorways, rear seat airbags, and different redundant programs and lacks a steering wheel.


Apple’s ongoing self-driving effort — code-named Mission Titan — made incremental regress in 2019, this yr’s report reveals. In contrast with 2018, a yr wherein Apple’s roughly 52 autonomous autos coated 79,745 miles, its vehicles drove solely 7,544 miles in complete.

With regards to disengagements, the corporate’s vehicles skilled 64 disengagements in 2019, versus final yr’s 871.65 disengagements per 1,000 miles with a disengagement roughly each 1.1 mile.

It hasn’t precisely been clean crusing for Mission Titan, which reportedly kicked off as early as 2014. Apple was solely permitted to check autonomous autos on California roads in 2017, lagging behind rivals like Waymo. And proposed technical collaborations with BMW and Mercedes-Benz failed, as did potential alliances with Nissan, BYD Auto, McClaren, and others.

Ultimately, Apple discovered a accomplice in Volkswagen, with which it produced an autonomous worker shuttle van primarily based on the automaker’s T6 Transporter business platform. However in 2018, Mission Titan suffered a blow when a former Apple worker was arrested by the FBI for allegedly stealing commerce secrets and techniques. In 2019, it suffered one other when Apple minimize the employees of roughly 5,000 workers by 200, shifting some to machine studying tasks.

Shortly afterward, former senior vice chairman of engineering at Tesla Doug Area grew to become the chief of the Titan crew, previous Apple’s acquisition of self-driving startup


Uber didn’t report a lot in the best way of progress concerning miles or disengagements in California for the yr 2019. (In 2018, it reported 2,608 disengagements per 1,000 miles, or zero.four miles per disengagement.) That’s as a result of in Could 2018, the corporate introduced it wouldn’t renew its allow to check self-driving autos in California, citing warning within the wake of a deadly accident involving considered one of its autonomous vehicles in Arizona.

Above: An autonomous Uber in San Francisco

Picture Credit score: Uber

That’s prone to change subsequent yr. In a bid to shut the hole with rivals together with GM’s Cruise Automation and Alphabet’s Waymo, Uber reapplied for a allow, which was granted earlier this month. It cautioned on the time that it didn’ have fast plans to have interaction in autonomous driving, though it’s eyeing San Francisco as a possible web site. As a substitute, Uber will kick off driving with skilled drivers behind the wheel and notify native, state, and federal stakeholders previous to launching driverless assessments.

In an S-1 submitting forward of its preliminary public providing final yr, Uber famous that its Superior Applied sciences Group — the division chargeable for its autonomous transportation tasks — has grown from a crew of 40 Pittsburgh-based researchers in 2015 to a 1,000-person workforce unfold throughout places of work in San Francisco and elsewhere. Moreover, it stated that it’s collected information from “tens of millions” of autonomous car testing miles thus far and accomplished “tens of hundreds” of passenger journeys thus far. And it’s gathering map information in Washington D.C., San Francisco, Dallas, and Toronto.


Aurora, which final yr raised investments from Amazon and different totaling $530 million at a valuation of over $2 billion, reported that its lidar sensor-, radar-, and camera-equipped Lincoln MKZs (which could within the subsequent yr be swapped out for Chrysler Pacific minivans) drove 39,729 miles (26,300 manually) and disengaged 10.6 per 1,000 miles in 2019. (Aurora blames 25% of the 142 reportable disengagements on a software program difficulty that was fastened early within the yr.) That’s in contrast with 11.5 per 1,000 miles in 2018.

Auora says that after a yr of specializing in capabilities together with merging, nudging, and unprotected left-hand turns, its autonomous system — the Aurora Driver, which has been built-in into six several types of autos thus far, together with sedans, SUVs, minivans, business vans, and Class eight freight vans — can carry out every seamlessly “even in dense city environments.” Because it expands its car fleets for information assortment, testing, and validation this yr, it plans to enhance how the Driver predicts and accounts for “non-compliant actors,” or individuals who aren’t following the foundations of the street, like jaywalkers and drivers who aggressively minimize into the lane.

Aurora has prioritized funding in its Digital Testing Suite, which permits it to run tens of millions of off-road assessments a day and feed driving selections into movement planning fashions, permitting them to study from expertise. Due to the Suite, Aurora can mannequin assessments involving pedestrians, lane merging, and parked vehicles; really, CEO Chris Urmson estimates that a single digital mile may be simply as insightful as 1,000 miles collected on the open street — and that in 2019, digital testing grew to over 735,000 assessments per day, a rise of over 100 occasions from 2018.

Aurora says that in a typical mile of driving in 2019, its autos encountered roughly 3 times extra vehicles on the street and practically ten occasions extra pedestrians in contrast with 2018. Plus, it says that the Aurora Driver improved in its capability to nudge (i.e., transfer round stagnant objects, like double-parked autos); navigate pedestrians, crosswalks, and visitors lights; make right-on-red onto roads with pace limits no higher than 25 miles per hour; make unprotected left turns that don’t contain a number of lanes; conduct lane adjustments; negotiate merges; and share the street with cyclists, the place it slows its pace behind them or merges with them if acceptable.

On the digital testing facet of the equation, Aurora claims that the Aurora Driver accomplished 2.27 million unprotected left turns in simulation earlier than making an attempt to carry out one on the street (in September 2019).  Now, that quantity stands at 31.28 million in simulation.


Driverless supply startup Nuro reported 68,762 complete miles pushed and 34 disengagements complete (2,022 miles per disengagement) in 2019, versus zero.97 disengagements per mile (1,zero28 miles per disengagements) in 2018. It listed 33 autos in its report as having collected autonomous miles in California, although it famous that this isn’t the whole thing of its fleet.

Nuro was cofounded in 2016 by Dave Ferguson and Jiajun Zhu, each veterans of the secretive Google self-driving automotive mission that ultimately spun out as Waymo. The Mountain View, California-based firm has about 400 workers and 100 contract employees and has up to now deployed over 75 supply autos, and it plans within the coming months to check 50 autos on roads in California, Arizona, and Texas, with security drivers behind the wheel.

In a step towards that objective, the corporate final week introduced that its R2 autos had been granted an autonomous car exemption by the U.S. Division of Transportation’s (DOT) Nationwide Freeway Site visitors Security Administration (NHTSA).

The R2 contains a extra sturdy physique that’s in a position to deal with a higher number of roads, climates, and climate circumstances than the outgoing R1. Its clean and rounded cabin, which has contours the place facet mirrors would in any other case be positioned, creates room for bicyclists and different “weak” street customers whereas enhancing lateral maneuverability.

The R2 will quickly be part of a fleet of self-driving Prius autos in Houston, Texas, making deliveries to shoppers on public roads from companions together with Domino’s, Walmart, and Kroger. Underneath the phrases of the exemption, Nuro might be permitted to supply and deploy not more than 5,000 R2 autos throughout a two-year interval, and it’ll need to report details about the R2’s operation (together with the automated driving system) and conduct outreach in communities the place it’s going to ship items. reported 174,845 miles pushed this yr, and 27 disengagements complete in 2019. In 2018, it stated that its vehicles disengaged zero.98 occasions per 1,000 miles, or as soon as each 1,022 miles.

The Guangzhou, China-based startup, which was based in 2014 by former Baidu chief architect James Peng and Google X veteran Tiancheng Lou, not too long ago concluded a multi-month pilot robo-taxi service in Irvine, California dubbed BotRide, in partnership with Hyundai (which supplied ONA Electrical SUVs) and By way of (which provided the passenger reserving and task logistics). It adopted on the heels of an April check of’s “product-ready” driverless vehicles in Nansha, China, and it marked one of many first robo-taxi companies to be made accessible in California.

Elsewhere, is collaborating with Toyota to discover “protected” mobility companies involving driverless know-how throughout a spread of segments and industries. The 2 corporations plan to kick off on a pilot program on public Beijing and Shanghai roads to “speed up the event and deployment” of autonomous autos, utilizing Lexus RX autos and’s driving system.

Above: A Hyundai KONA Electrical SUV outfitted with Pony,ai’s autonomous navigation tech.

Picture Credit score:’s full-stack platform, PonyAlpha, leverages lidars, radars, and cameras to maintain tabs on obstacles inside as much as 200 meters of its self-driving vehicles. It serves as the inspiration for the corporate’s totally autonomous vans and freight supply resolution, which commenced testing on public roads in April, and it’s deployed in check vehicles throughout the metropolis limits of Fremont, California and Beijing (along with Guangzhou).


Tesla reported zero miles pushed autonomously on public roads in California throughout all of 2019, because it has for the previous three years. The corporate says that it conducts its testing by way of simulation, in laboratories, on check tracks, and on public roads in numerous areas all over the world, and that it “shadow-tests” its vehicles’ autonomous capabilities by accumulating anonymized information from over 400,000 customer-owned autos “throughout regular driving operations.”

Telsa’s Autopilot — the software program layer operating atop its customized chips — is successfully a complicated driver help system (ADAS) that faucets machine studying algorithms and an array of cameras, ultrasonic sensors, and radars to carry out self-parking, lane-centering, adaptive cruise management, freeway lane-changing, and different feats. The corporate beforehand introduced that vehicles with Full Self-Driving Functionality, a premium Autopilot package deal, will sometime achieve the flexibility to “computerized[ally] driving on metropolis streets” and “acknowledge and reply to visitors lights and cease indicators.”

In its most up-to-date voluntary security report protecting This fall 2019, Tesla stated that it registered one accident for each three.07 million miles pushed wherein drivers had Autopilot engaged. And in line with a mannequin developed by MIT researcher Lex Fridman, its vehicles are estimated to have pushed practically 2 billion miles in autonomous mode,


In complete, the DMV says that …. corporations reported driving …. million miles in autonomous mode on California roads and highways, up from 48 corporations and a pair of million miles in 2018. About 65 corporations have the DMV’s go-ahead to check self-driving autos on public California roads, which is completely different than the permits issued by the California Public Utilities Fee (CPUC) to move passengers in autonomous autos. Solely 5 corporations  — Aurora, AutoX,, Waymo, and Zoox — have permits underneath the CPUC’s pilot program, with Zoox being the primary to obtain one in December 2018.

However whether or not the disengagement metrics talk something significant stays the topic of ongoing debate.

Aurora, for one, has famous that they don’t adequately seize enhancements or their affect over time. That’s why the corporate data two sorts internally: reactionary disengagements, the place a car operator disengages the system as a result of they consider an unsafe state of affairs may happen, and coverage disengagements, the place an operator proactively disengages forward of an on-road state of affairs the system hasn’t been taught to deal with.

Urmson claims that technical or engineering velocity is a superior measure of progress as a result of it captures developments made on core know-how. “Traditionally, the trade and media have turned to tallying on-road miles and calculating disengagement charges as measurements of progress,” he wrote in a Medium put up. “If we drive 100 million miles in a flat, dry space the place there aren’t any different autos or folks, and few intersections, is our ‘disengagement price’ actually corresponding to driving 100 miles in a busy and sophisticated metropolis like Pittsburgh.”

In a weblog put up earlier this yr, Kyle Vogt, cofounder and CTO of Cruise, posited it may be time for a brand new metric for reporting security of self-driving vehicles. “Needless to say driving on a well-marked freeway or large, suburban roads will not be the identical as driving in a chaotic city setting,” Vogt wrote. “The distinction in talent required is rather like snowboarding on inexperienced slopes vs. double black diamonds.”

Vogt and Urmson aren’t the one ones who’ve voiced their disapproval of disengagement-based security measures.

San Francisco-based self-driving truck startup Embark, which final yr launched a voluntary disengagement report, declined to reveal numbers in favor of a brand new system of metrics “that [capture] the completely different eventualities” its system encounters. (Regardless of this, it revealed that in 2019, it examined 449,837 automated miles with zero crashes.) “Throughout the firm, we now have migrated away from utilizing disengagement price as a efficiency metric, and to stay in line with our inside considering, we now have determined to not launch a 2019 disengagement report,” wrote Embark CEO Alex Rodrigues in a Medium put up.

Apple has referred to as on the DMV to “amend or make clear” its place on disengagement and testing with out security drivers, and in a weblog put up this month, Waymo wrote that “the important thing to self-driving know-how safely enhancing and scaling is thru a sturdy breadth of expertise and state of affairs testing, represented by a wider array of knowledge factors past disengagement alone.”

“We respect what the California DMV was making an attempt to do when creating this requirement, however the disengagement metric doesn’t present related insights into the capabilities of the Waymo Driver or distinguish its efficiency from others within the self-driving area,” wrote Waymo in a collection of tweets in the present day. “Whereas many of the growth, studying, and validation of the Waymo Driver comes via billions of miles pushed inside our simulation environments, our real-world driving expertise is primarily outdoors of California, in markets like Detroit, Los Angeles, and Phoenix. Most of our large-scale real-world driving, which is crucial for full-system validation (together with validating the realism of our simulator) comes from Phoenix.”

Nuro CEO Jiajun Zhu stated in an announcement that the metrics for miles pushed and miles pushed per disengagement are “not a complete measure” for technological success, enterprise maturity, or security. “We view the autonomous car disengagement reviews as a chance to amplify the excellent security methods utilized by Nuro to develop our autonomous know-how,” he continued. “We additionally proceed our engagement with regulators on how our distinctive car design and operations prioritizes the protection of others with whom we share the roads.”

In a dialog with VentureBeat, Dmitry Polishchuk, the pinnacle of Russian tech big Yandex’s autonomous automotive mission, famous that Yandex hasn’t launched a disengagement report back to date because of this. “We’ve type of been ready for some kind of trade commonplace,” he stated. “Self-driving corporations aren’t following the very same protocols for issues. [For example, there might be a] disengagement as a result of there’s one thing blocking the appropriate lane or a automotive in the appropriate lane, and [the safety driver realizes] as a human that [this object or car] isn’t going to maneuver.”

Stalled regulation and skepticism

Sadly for corporations like Yandex, Cruise, and Aurora, much less regulatory steerage 00 no more — appears the likelier near-future path, a minimum of within the U.S. At CES on January eight, Transportation Secretary Elaine Chao introduced Automated Autos (AV, new pointers concerning self-driving vehicles that search to advertise “voluntary consensus requirements” amongst autonomous car builders. It requests however doesn’t mandate common assessments on self-driving car security, and it permits these assessments to be accomplished by automakers themselves versus by a requirements physique.

Advocacy teams together with the Advocates for Freeway and Auto Security virtually instantly criticized the coverage for its vagueness. “With out robust management and rules … [autonomous vehicle] producers can and can proceed to introduce extraordinarily complicated supercomputers-on-wheels onto public roads … with meager authorities oversight,” Advocates president Cathy Chase stated in an announcement. “Voluntary pointers are utterly unenforceable, won’t lead to ample efficiency requirements, and fall effectively in need of the safeguards which might be essential to guard the general public.”

Within the U.S., laws stays stalled on the federal degree, sadly. Greater than a yr in the past, the Home unanimously handed the SELF DRIVE Act, which might create a regulatory framework for autonomous autos. However it has but to be taken up by the Senate, which in 2018 tabled a separate invoice, the AV START Act, that made its manner via committee in November 2017.

There’s proof the standstill is contributing to public consternation about self-driving vehicles. J.D. Energy’s inaugural 2019 Mobility Confidence Index Research discovered that a majority of respondents harbor doubts concerning the know-how’s robustness, with 71% saying that they’re frightened about driverless system failures or errors and 57% saying they worry malicious car hacks. It was roughly according to outcomes from a PSB Analysis survey commissioned by Intel final yr, which indicated that almost half (43%) of individuals don’t really feel protected round them, and a current CarGuru survey of 1,146 vehicle house owners that discovered that 87% wouldn’t depend on autonomous vehicles given the selection.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *