The grid battery fireplace in Arizona final yr ended with an explosion, however disagreement has emerged on how precisely it started.
Proprietor Arizona Public Service just lately concluded defect in a single lithium-ion battery cell precipitated it to warmth up, triggering a series response that destroyed a complete rack and launched gases that later exploded. However LG Chem, the producer accountable for the battery cells and modules, revealed its personal report with a distinct conclusion.
In accordance with LG Chem’s “progress report,” compiled by scientific investigation agency Exponent, the bodily proof doesn’t assist the battery defect idea. The report, filed with Arizona’s utility regulators final month, as a substitute theorizes that exterior causes heated up the battery.
At stake is the fame of a long-time chief within the lithium-ion manufacturing house. Batteries are recognized to degrade over time, typically forming spindly metallic deposits referred to as dendrites, which may finally attain throughout a cell and trigger a brief. When a brief circuit heats up, it could actually set off thermal runaway. However for LG Chem’s cells to exhibit such conduct in simply two years — the age of the battery system in Arizona when the incident occurred — would represent a producing failure.
“The APS occasion is well-known, so when a report will get revealed as the ultimate report, that does generate numerous questions,” stated Peter Gibson, vp of power storage at LG Chem, in a latest interview. “We felt a have to make it clear that the report was not in keeping with our views.”
APS declined to touch upon LG Chem’s strategies or findings.
“We stand by the investigation we led into the April 2019 McMicken occasion and the unbiased report we commissioned to compile knowledgeable evaluation into our last findings,” spokesperson Jenna Rowell stated in an e-mail. “The report we launched displays the teachings we discovered and can information APS’s future actions with battery power storage.”
The utility’s new necessities ought to rule out the explosive final result, even when one other battery cell heats up. In that sense, whether or not or not a selected cell kicked off the McMicken catastrophe has little bearing on the protection of future tasks.
The stakes of the conflicting report have extra to do with LG Chem’s fame as a accountable battery producer, and the trade’s understanding of the dangers of lithium-ion battery know-how.
Conflicting explanations of the foundation trigger
APS introduced in power consultancy DNV GL to jot down its report; that agency reviewed the forensic investigation findings to compile its conclusions. Exponent, a agency that focuses on investigating battery failures, carried out its personal testing.
The wreckage posed an epistemological drawback for investigators, as a result of the cell at floor zero for thermal runaway burned up within the course of. With out conclusive proof from the supply, investigators needed to look to fragmentary clues to piece collectively what occurred.
Cells taken at random from elsewhere within the battery system, and from its twin system at Pageant Ranch, confirmed “lithium metallic deposition and irregular dendritic development,” DNV GL notes.
“As a result of the proof of Lithium metallic deposition and irregular dendritic development was sufficiently current within the random samples that had been analyzed, it was decided to an inexpensive diploma of scientific certainty to be the anomaly that precipitated the preliminary cell failure and ensuing thermal runaway,” battery security knowledgeable Davion Hill wrote within the APS report.
However LG Chem asserts the investigation wanted to think about different explanations. “A cell failure might be brought on by both a brief circuit or heating from an exterior supply,” Gibson stated. “Any severe evaluation wants to think about each.”
LG Chem examined one of these metallic deposits, and located that it didn’t conduct electrical energy and was unlikely to be pure lithium metallic.
“It’s unimaginable for a non-conductive deposit to determine an inner cell brief circuit, carry present, resistively warmth and trigger thermal runaway,” Exponent’s report says.
Nonetheless, Exponent additionally notes that a number of the deposit samples reacted in air in manners in keeping with lithium metallic. “It’s troublesome to reconcile the info that the deposits have been proven to be non-conductive and that they’ve reactivity in air that’s just like that of conductive lithium metallic,” the report explains.
Excessive lithium plating, of the kind that might trigger a brief circuit, essentially reduces the cell’s means to retailer power, which might result in a decline in efficiency. Nevertheless it’s not clear if a discount in a single cell’s efficiency might present up within the information logs. The Exponent report features a part on “Failure Knowledge Limitations” that exhibits how McMicken’s information logging didn’t seize a granular image of what transpired on the cell stage.
Exponent additionally discovered bodily indicators arcing within the battery rack, which might have supplied an exterior warmth supply to provoke thermal runaway. It discovered that the harm on the batteries signifies an “assault” by an exterior warmth supply.
These observations elevate questions on timeline, which can be unimaginable to resolve. If a metallic deposit appeared non-conductive when LG Chem examined it, was it additionally non-conductive when it first shaped, or when the thermal runaway started? Did the electrical arcing that left marks on the rack occur proper earlier than the thermal runaway, or within the chaos that ensued?
Reputational harm management
Even when observers did blame LG Chem’s cell for beginning the fireplace, it’s not clear that this would significantly have an effect on the corporate’s prospects.
Each studies agree that the actual harm got here from different components, specifically the propagation of thermal runaway and the buildup of un-vented explosive fuel. Battery builders acknowledge that particular person cells typically fail; the trade since has made headway in designing programs to restrict the harm of a single cell failure.
LG Chem has handled fires at amenities it equipped earlier than. After South Korea paid out a beneficiant subsidy for battery tasks, enterprise boomed, after which a spate of battery fires broke out. Round a dozen of them occurred at tasks equipped by LG Chem, Gibson stated.
“In Korea, there have been an terrible lot of programs developed by comparatively inexperienced system integrators,” he stated.
Some tasks revealed elementary design issues, evidenced by issues like rust and water leakage. After investigating the issue, the Korean authorities beneficial limiting the most state of cost. At that time, LG Chem proactively exchanged battery modules from that period as a further security precaution, Gibson stated.
“If we see one thing the place there’s actually a have to do a retrofit to reinforce security…we’re very proactive,” Gibson stated. “It occurs very not often.”
That episode didn’t dislodge LG Chem from its Tier 1 cell provider standing, nor did it jeopardize the enterprise of supplying electrical automobile batteries to automakers like GM. LG Chem’s automotive battery enterprise is roughly 10 occasions bigger than its stationary grid storage enterprise, Gibson stated.
No matter occurred at McMicken, it hasn’t shaken the belief of Fluence, which purchased the cells from LG Chem and built-in them into the system for APS.
When requested if Fluence nonetheless buys from LG Chem, COO John Zahurancik stated, “We work intently with a number of prime tier battery suppliers, together with LG, to make sure the protection and high quality of battery cells utilized in our programs. In no way would we ever think about using battery know-how we didn’t consider could possibly be deployed and operated safely.”
Even after the McMicken fireplace, LG Chem cells discovered a house in LS Energy’s Gateway storage facility, the biggest lithium-ion battery on this planet. LG Chem’s security requirements satisfied LS Energy that it was a sensible choice to produce 250 megawatts for the Southern California plant, which started operations this summer time.
Different chemistries rising
A broader shift in buyer desire is underway within the grid battery sector, nevertheless.
The stationary storage trade obtained an early enhance from piggybacking on the provision chains for the electrical automobile trade. The power dense nickel-manganese-cobalt-oxide (NMC) batteries designed for vehicles doubled as highly effective batteries for the grid.
However the APS fireplace strikingly illustrated the explosive potential of these NMC batteries. One other chemistry, lithium-ferrous-phosphate or LFP, has gained floor attributable to a fame for security and decrease prices, though it packs much less power density.
“The protection query has been one among a number of the explanation why the power storage market has given the Chinese language LFP distributors a more durable look,” stated Daniel Finn-Foley, power storage director at Wooden Mackenzie. “As they’ve given them a re-assessment, they’re liking what they see and it’s transferring LFP distributors towards a market-leading place.”
Certainly, NMC’s market share for grid storage has already peaked and can proceed to say no as LFP positive aspects floor, in accordance with new analysis from Wooden Mackenzie. LFP equipped simply 10 p.c of the market in 2015, however will attain 30 p.c by 2030.
That shift elevates producers in China who weren’t thought of Tier 1 within the early days of U.S. grid battery growth. However the development doesn’t essentially imply LG Chem can be left behind.
The South Korean firm maintains ample technical expertise to develop and commercialize new chemistries because the market calls for. LG Chem has produced LFP prior to now, Gibson famous, however he’s “nonetheless very a lot of the opinion that NMC is most well-liked,” attributable to its energy density and efficiency traits.
If the market shifts because the analysts predict, it’s going to coincide with meteoric development in storage deployments. Meaning NMC would serve a smaller slice of a a lot bigger pie than right now’s grid storage market.
That is the second in a collection of exploring the repercussions of probably the most outstanding battery fireplace in latest U.S. historical past. The primary installment, on how the storage trade has already improved its security procedures, is offered right here