US Commerce Courtroom Sides with Longi, Jinko, REC in Photo voltaic Patent Infringement Case

US Commerce Courtroom Sides with Longi, Jinko, REC in Photo voltaic Patent Infringement Case

Longi Photo voltaic, JinkoSolar and REC Group seem to have emerged victorious from a authorized try and shut these producers out of the U.S. market.

In a criticism filed in March, Hanwha Q Cells alleged that each one three corporations have been infringing on a patent filed in 2008 by importing cells and modules that used proprietary know-how.  

The case is now stayed, with a judgement of non-infringement anticipated inside the subsequent two weeks, in line with a late Tuesday submitting from the U.S. Worldwide Commerce Fee. The willpower applies to all three of the businesses named in Hanwha’s criticism. 

In a press release on the choice, JinkoSolar mentioned the choice affirms its place that Hanwha’s allegations have been “with out technical or authorized benefit.” REC, Longi and Hanwha didn’t instantly reply to requests for touch upon the choice. 

Although the USITC has but to launch its willpower, the courtroom wrapped up deliberations lengthy earlier than anticipated. A listening to on the case was slated to start out November 22, with a authorized timeline stretching into 2020. 

Hanwha does have a number of avenues to problem the antagonistic consequence. The South Korea-based producer can enchantment to U.S. ITC commissioners for a evaluation of the choice, which was made by an administrative regulation choose assigned to the case. After that, Hanwha also can enchantment to the U.S. Courtroom of Appeals for the Federal Circuit. However reversing the choice could also be a longshot, in line with John Smirnow, common counsel and vice chairman of market technique on the Photo voltaic Power Industries Affiliation. 

“It might be a big uphill battle for Hanwha to get this reversed,” mentioned Smirnow. “At this stage, the choose is principally saying, ‘I’ve seen all of the proof and based mostly on every little thing I do know right this moment these corporations usually are not infringing on Hanwha’s patent.’” 

SEIA, together with a number of different photo voltaic builders, argued in public feedback on the case that a constructive consequence for Hanwha would harm the photo voltaic business by locking out suppliers at a necessary time for the U.S. business. 

Wooden Mackenzie Energy & Renewables expects the U.S. market to stay in undersupply via This fall for monocrystalline PERC merchandise, as builders stockpile modules and different gear within the leadup to the phaseout of the Funding Tax Credit score and proceed to deal with Part 201 tariffs. 

Whereas these provide constraints are anticipated to loosen in 2020, the go well with had probably broad implications for the U.S. photo voltaic market. JinkoSolar is the most important producer of modules globally, with over 16 gigawatts of capability. Longi will not be far behind, with 15 gigawatts, in line with knowledge from WoodMac. All three of the respondents in addition to Hanwha are among the many world’s largest producers of mono PERC cells and modules, the know-how the photo voltaic business now favors. 

Through the keep and potential appeals, imports from REC, Longi and Jinko can proceed. Hanwha can also be pursuing comparable circumstances in Australia, towards solely Jinko and Longi, and in Germany, towards solely Jinko and REC. Each of these challenges are ongoing. 

WoodMac senior photo voltaic analyst Xiaojing Solar mentioned the go well with factors to “the confrontational or protectionist” dynamics presently at play amongst producers trying to get an edge within the U.S. The business can also be now at odds over the Part 201 exclusion the Trump administration granted for bifacial photo voltaic panels, however then reversed. 

“Producers are leveraging a broad array of approaches to guard their U.S. market share, together with pricey lawsuits and lobbying efforts,” mentioned Solar. “Producers like First Photo voltaic and Hanwha, and beforehand SolarWorld and Suniva, are main the cost to impose and maintain tariffs.”

These disagreements could also be sorted out behind-the-scenes at SEIA; each Jinko and Hanwha now sit on the group’s board, with the previous formally becoming a member of right this moment.

Back to Top