Dominion Power made large information final week with its pledge to go net-zero by 2050. It is likely one of the largest utilities to make this kind of pledge to this point, with roughly the identical variety of prospects as energy large Duke Power. And that is a part of a wave within the utility sector, coming just a few weeks after Arizona Public Service introduced its internet zero pledge.
Like many different utility pledges, this transfer is related to pending coverage change that may power Dominion to decarbonize. The definitive passage of the landmark Virginia Clear Economic system Act by Virginia’s state home the identical day as Dominion introduced its plan was in all probability not a coincidence.
Nevertheless, just like the pledge by Xcel which led the best way within the utility sector, this transfer goes past a single state-level coverage; Dominion operates in 18 states. And right here it is very important once more word the position of different pressures, as the ability and fuel firm has been criticized for its position in pushing the Atlantic Coast Pipeline.
It is usually a novel improvement that this pledge addresses not solely CO2, but in addition methane.
This factors to what’s completely different about Dominion’s pledge. It’s one factor for a utility that provides electrical energy to announce plans to scrub its fleet, however it’s a completely different matter for utilities that additionally provide fossil fuels for warmth as the idea of a enterprise.
Amongst the utilities making internet zero or 100 p.c clear vitality pledges each DTE and Xcel each provide fuel to their prospects, however Dominion is the second-largest provider of fuel within the nation, with three.three million prospects in 5 states versus 1.eight million for Xcel. The corporate additionally owns roughly 100,000 miles of pure fuel pipelines and is the second-largest operator of fuel storage within the nation.
It is usually a novel improvement that this pledge addresses not solely CO2, but in addition methane (CH4), a greenhouse fuel which is way stronger on quick timeframes, and which because of this has the potential to super-charge short-term warming. And its plans round methane contain sources that haven’t obtained a lot consideration to this point.
Nevertheless, on the finish of the day Dominion’s plans deal with a slender portion of its carbon air pollution, and go away an enormous gap across the emissions concerned within the sale of fuel to its prospects.
Methane is the first part of the pure fuel that Dominion and different utilities ship to their prospects. When burned, pure fuel produces much less CO2 emissions per unit of energy delivered than coal, and the shift from coal to fuel has been the first issue within the fall in U.S. energy sector CO2 emissions over the previous twenty years.
Nevertheless, it’s a utterly completely different story when pure fuel methane escapes immediately into the ambiance earlier than it’s combusted for electrical energy era or warmth. In accordance with the Intergovernmental Panel on Local weather Change, methane is greater than 80 occasions as highly effective on a 20-year timeframe, and roughly 30 occasions as highly effective on a 100-year timeframe. If a lot of this methane escapes when pure fuel is extracted from the bottom, moved by pipelines and distributed into buildings, it will probably have a big effect on local weather, and might name into query how preferable it’s to coal as an vitality useful resource.
Compounding the issue is a scarcity of readability across the quantity of methane that escapes throughout fuel manufacturing, transmission and distribution. In response to this problem, RMI is working with SYSTEMIQ to convey extra transparency to the methane emissions image with the Local weather Motion Engine, an analytic device designed to pinpoint the place methane is escaping from oil and fuel operations in order that producers can take swift motion. The institute can also be working with fuel suppliers and patrons to ascertain a certification normal for pure fuel produced with minimal methane emissions, so patrons can supply an environmentally preferable product.
However the oil and fuel business isn’t the one supply of pure fuel, which can also be emitted as a waste product from landfills, water therapy and industrial animal farming. Dominion is trying towards this “biogas” as one other device in its decarbonization toolbox.
Biogas and hog manure
Dominion’s pledge to get to internet zero when it comes to each CO2 and methane isn’t the corporate’s first transfer on this area; the corporate estimates that it already has decreased methane emissions by 25 p.c versus 2010 ranges. It now plans 65 p.c internet reductions in emissions by 2030 and 80 p.c by 2040.
Dominion is planning to sort out its methane emissions on two fronts. First, it can give attention to lowering methane from three sources inside its management: fuel venting that happens throughout upkeep and inspection actions, changing getting old gear liable to leakage, and increasing leak detection packages. Second, recognizing that it might be unable to remove methane leaks solely, it plans to offset remaining methane emissions by procuring biogas, generally referred to as renewable pure fuel (RNG).
Dominion is planning to sort out its methane emissions on two fronts.
It is a crucial and oft-overlooked distinction between net-zero and zero-emissions pledges. The latter means eliminating all sources of emissions, and the previous can embody offsets. Dominion’s language on this regard is evident. “The corporate has dedicated to put money into carbon-beneficial RNG tasks that may seize an quantity of methane from U.S. farms no less than equal to any remaining methane and carbon dioxide emissions from the corporate’s pure fuel operations,” reads Dominion’s announcement.
Cate Hight, a principal with RMI’s Trade Apply, notes that there are limits to this strategy. “Investing in biogas seize tasks is an effective factor, as these tasks cut back methane emissions and supply another gas supply to traditional pure fuel in sure geographies,” asserts Hight. Nevertheless, such investments “don’t remedy the most important methane downside we at the moment have on our arms, which is methane launched throughout typical oil and fuel manufacturing.”
And if Dominion is stressing the position of biogas, different elements could also be at play. Throughout Hurricane Florence in 2018, two lagoons of hog manure overflowed in North Carolina, which precipitated 7 million gallons of hog waste to spill and ultimately stream into the South River.
The lagoons belonged to North Carolina’s largest hog farmer, Smithfield, and likely didn’t enhance relations with its “downstream” neighbors. Lower than two months later, the corporate established a partnership with Dominion to seize the methane from its operations — together with capped lagoons. This partnership since has expanded to a $500 million deal for Smithfield to produce Dominion with biogas.
Plugging the leaks
In the long run, RMI’s Cate Hight says that this is a vital improvement for the motion to handle the methane emissions related to pure fuel manufacturing and use, which she says has been constructing because the first “accountable pure fuel” deal in 2018.
It stays to be seen if Dominion will embody in its future plans efforts to remove or offset the methane emissions related to the entire worth chain of the pure fuel it makes use of, together with the fuel manufacturing section, which its current announcement doesn’t deal with.
Investing in biogas seize tasks is sweet however would not remedy the most important methane downside, which is methane launched throughout typical oil and fuel manufacturing.
These emissions are a significant focus of the most important oil producers, together with BP, which final week introduced a zero-carbon pledge that features plans to put in methane measurement in any respect of its main oil and fuel processing websites by 2023. Hight notes main fuel patrons reminiscent of Dominion have a possibility to extend the stress on fuel suppliers to handle their methane emissions and improve the effectiveness of such zero-carbon pledges.
“This demand for a lower-methane emission pure fuel product, mixed with elevated transparency about the place methane emissions are taking place, goes to be a extremely successful mixture,” states Hight.
Nevertheless, it is very important not let Dominion’s work on methane leaks cloud bigger points. The utility’s plan to achieve internet zero isn’t the identical because the zero-carbon pledges of electrical utilities; beneath Dominion’s plan, it can nonetheless promote fuel to end-customers, and even when Dominion plugs all of the leaks in its transmission and distribution networks, its operations nonetheless will lead to emissions on the level of combustion.
As well as, Dominion’s dedication doesn’t consider the methane emissions related to fuel manufacturing, which account for over 50 p.c of the methane downside within the oil and fuel worth chain. The utility additionally stays a member of the American Gasoline Affiliation, which has led the struggle in opposition to constructing electrification.
So whereas the hogs at the moment are taking part in their half, there are greater fish to fry.